Hidden Gems: Underrated Islands in the U.S. to Explore
1. San Juan Islands, Washington
Nestled between the U.S. and Canada, the San Juan Islands are a serene escape from the bustle of mainland life. Comprising over 170 islands, each offers unique charm and natural beauty. Orcas Island, for instance, is known for its lush forests and hilly landscapes, perfect for hiking and whale watching. Visit Moran State Park to hike Mount Constitution for panoramic views, or explore the quaint village of Eastsound.
On San Juan Island, history lovers should not miss the American Camp and British Camp sites, remnants from the 19th-century Pig War. For nature enthusiasts, consider taking a kayak tour to spot sea lions and porpoises. The islands are also renowned for their farm-to-table dining scene, offering fresh local seafood and organic produce.
2. Ocracoke Island, North Carolina
Accessible only by ferry, Ocracoke Island remains one of North Carolina’s best-kept secrets. Part of the Outer Banks, Ocracoke is famous for its unspoiled beaches and relaxed atmosphere. The island boasts stunning stretches of shoreline where visitors can swim, fish, or simply unwind.
Ocracoke Village, with its historic lighthouse and charming cottages, invites exploration. The island also features unique dining experiences, such as Howard’s Pub, renowned for its seafood. Don’t miss the opportunity to take a guided kayak tour through the salt marshes, where you might spot wild ponies or various bird species.
3. Put-in-Bay, Ohio
Located on South Bass Island in Lake Erie, Put-in-Bay is an ideal getaway for those seeking leisure and adventure. Known for its vibrant nightlife and outdoor recreational activities, the island offers a unique combination of fun and relaxation.
Begin your visit with a trip to Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial, an iconic landmark commemorating a pivotal War of 1812 battle. For wine lovers, local wineries offer tastings and vineyard tours. Adventurers can explore the island on rented golf carts or bicycles, visiting sites such as the quaint Butterfly House and the scenic caves.
4. Ellis Island, New Jersey
Most people know Ellis Island as the historic immigration station, but it’s also a quiet oasis amidst the busy New York Harbor. The island is home to the Ellis Island National Museum of Immigration, where visitors can delve into the rich history of millions who passed through its doors.
Walk through the restored Great Hall, and learn about your family’s immigration history with the available online databases. Spend time taking in stunning views of the Statue of Liberty and Manhattan skyline. The island hosts beautiful gardens, perfect for reflection, offering a unique blend of history and tranquility.
5. Cumberland Island, Georgia
Cumberland Island, Georgia’s largest barrier island, is a treasure trove of natural beauty and historical significance. Accessible only by ferry, it’s a great spot for nature lovers and history buffs alike. The island is home to wild horses, pristine beaches, and oak groves draped with Spanish moss.
Exploring the ruins of the Carnegie family’s Dungeness mansion adds a historical touch to the experience. Visitors can hike the trails that weave through the island or indulge in a guided tour for deeper insights. Birdwatchers will appreciate the rich avian diversity, with many species spotted year-round.
6. Mackinac Island, Michigan
Steeped in history and charm, Mackinac Island is car-free and filled with horse-drawn carriages and bicycles. The island is famous for its fudge, and visitors should indulge in a sweet treat from one of the many fudge shops.
Explore Fort Mackinac and learn about its role in the War of 1812, or hike through Mackinac Island State Park, which covers over 80% of the island. The spectacular views from Arch Rock are not to be missed, as they provide an excellent vista of Lake Huron.
7. Jekyll Island, Georgia
Jekyll Island is a premier vacation destination featuring pristine beaches and rich history. Once a private retreat for America’s elite, remnants of the Jekyll Island Club can be explored in the state park.
Engage with the island’s natural environment at the Georgia Sea Turtle Center, dedicated to the conservation of sea turtles. Don’t miss the scenic Driftwood Beach, where weathered trees create a stunning backdrop for photography. Cycling is a popular way to explore the island, with designated bike paths winding through picturesque landscapes.
8. South Padre Island, Texas
South Padre Island is often overshadowed by other Texan destinations, yet it offers beautiful beaches and a laid-back vibe. The island is known for its water sports, including kiteboarding, parasailing, and fishing.
Nature lovers can visit the South Padre Island Birding and Nature Center where hundreds of migratory bird species can be observed. Beach-goers can enjoy some of the cleanest shores in the state, perfect for sunbathing or relaxing with local Mexican cuisine.
9. Parker Island, Florida
Situated off the coast of St. Augustine, Parker Island is an escape into quietude where you can enjoy nature without the crowds. Known for its fishing and eco-tourism, the island is surrounded by clear waters and lush landscapes.
Go paddleboarding or take a kayak tour through the mangroves, offering a chance to see dolphins and other marine life. Small beach areas allow for intimate picnics and sun-soaking away from the busy tourist spots, perfect for a peaceful retreat.
10. Block Island, Rhode Island
Block Island is a tranquil getaway characterized by its dramatic cliffs and clean beaches. The island features miles of pristine nature trails, such as those in the Block Island National Wildlife Refuge, perfect for hiking and bike rides.
Explore the local shops and eateries in the charming town of New Shoreham, or spend your day at the beach. The Mohegan Bluffs on the southern shore provide breathtaking views of the Atlantic Ocean, while the lighthouse adds a touch of history to your visit.
11. Tangier Island, Virginia
Tangier Island offers a glimpse into a simpler way of life on the Chesapeake Bay. With a small population, this island is known for its crabbing and fishing culture. Travelers can explore the island via bicycles or golf carts, as cars are not allowed.
Visit local eateries to taste the day’s fresh catch, or engage in a guided tour to learn about the island’s history and ecology. The friendly locals provide a welcoming atmosphere, making it easy to immerse yourself in island life.
12. Santa Cruz Island, California
As part of Channel Islands National Park, Santa Cruz Island boasts dramatic cliffs, secluded beaches, and rich marine life. The island is ideal for hiking, kayaking, and snorkeling, with numerous trails available for exploration.
Don’t miss the Painted Cave, often cited as one of the most beautiful sea caves in the world. Visitors can spot a variety of wildlife, including seals and dolphins. Overnight camping is available for those wishing to experience the island’s tranquility more intimately.
13. Sausalito, California
Technically part of Marin County, Sausalito feels like its own world. Just a short ferry ride from San Francisco, it offers stunning views of the Bay and a unique blend of art, food, and outdoor activities.
Stroll the waterfront and explore local galleries, or dine with a view at waterfront restaurants. Take advantage of the nearby hiking and biking opportunities in the Marin Headlands, where you’ll enjoy breathtaking vistas and the chance to connect with nature.
14. Bainbridge Island, Washington
Just a short ferry ride from Seattle, Bainbridge Island embodies the quintessential Pacific Northwest vibe with its lush greenery and picturesque waterfront. Explore the local shops, cafes, and art galleries in Winslow, the island’s main town.
Outdoor enthusiasts can hike on scenic trails or relax on one of its beaches. The Bainbridge Island Museum of Art, featuring contemporary pieces from local artists, offers a cultural touch to your visit.
15. Fletcher Island, Florida
A hidden treasure in the Florida Keys, Fletcher Island remains largely untouched by mass tourism. The island is ideal for snorkeling, with abundant coral reefs and marine life.
Visitors can enjoy a peaceful day at the beach or partake in beachcombing and birdwatching. Campgrounds allow for an immersive experience in this off-the-beaten-path paradise, where relaxation is the order of the day.
Exploring these underrated islands reveals a wealth of hidden gems that offer unique insights into local culture, history, and natural beauty—all away from the mainstream tourist crowds.
